If you’re willing to expand your price range a bit, then I’d say the G5. Or you could get it off of the BST. Although it is a bit lighter than your preferences, it’s a great yo-yo. BBYY yo-yos are heavier, you could try those.
Hey I think the Wedgie might actually be a better choice for you because you mentioned 5a too, and it’s great for both 1a and 5a. The shape still fits your preferences, I would say the Wedgie.
Wedgie is undersized. He want’s large. And the Bully is better than the Wedgie at 5A in my opinion. Most people prefer bigger, heavier yo-yos such as the Black Knight or Bully.
Have you ever thrown a All Metal Yo? They hit your hand hard. A Metal Rimmed Yo is not as bad unless its a xcon size rim. But even that isnt that bad. Plastics are way softer for Errors/Fail.
Borrow a All Metal first before you go out and buy, or trade for a FHZ metal before you invest. This will give you an Idea of what your dealing with.
You may justs like something a bit cheaper and Softer IMO.
I don’t know how far along you are with string smoothness and a all metal will Tear you up quick.