Here’s what I carry my yoyos in. Unfortunately, these cases do not fit all of my yoyos. I have about 20 more that are not able to fit. These cases also double as what I take with me to yoyo meets too.
I saw a design on the Web somewhere that was basically a pegboard with a bunch of hair scrunchies poked through it. I cut a piece of pegboard to fit on the back of one of my closet shelves. The yoyos face out, and the shelf below it provides space for random miscellanea like strings and bearings that I’m experimenting with. In the space I have, there’s room for about 24 throws.
One nice thing about this is that, if I make a little stand for it, I can take it to demonstrations and show people the variety of yoyos that are out there. Removing one from the pegboard takes a little more than just a grab, which lowers the probability of theft slightly.
Considering that small ones only cost around $7 I just might pick up a small one and a larger case. The small cases should hold around 8-10 if spaced properly