Can’t Decide. They are all so sick.
What do you want in a yoyo? Floaty? Solid? Stable? Fast? Slow? What are you preferences 
Moderately floaty. Id like it to be pretty stable and I don’t play super fast.
Price range?
All of them qualify for stable.
The Gnarwal is small and can get quite a mover. The Chief is a mover. Neither are very floaty to me.
The Cliff is big and more floaty.
The Nessie is more competition drive and not floaty.
The Wrath would be pretty good
I haven’t played the Crucial Confection, so I say nothing. Given an opportunity, I would like to try one.
Chief isn’t floaty??? It’s like the floatiest yoyo I’ve throw. Hm
I chose the wrath… that thing is amazing even though I don’t own one.
The cliff is awsome 8) http://shop.yoyoexpert.com/product/870/CLYW-CLIFF it has a cool design and is a great throw!!!