Rather than necro an old thread from 2014, I thought I’d just start a fresh one on this subject.
So list your yoyo shape preferences in order from favorite to least favorite.
For me it’s:
H, rounded “soft” V
V, W
O (least favorite)
I know that organics are very comfortable, but they just don’t appeal to me for some reason. I’d much rather have comfort in the form of a nicely rounded H or V.
O is great but really hard to get right, I think. It would be my first preference, but so few manufacturers can do it properly. So many just feel lifeless and heavy.
I like W and H the most, I find O a bit hard to warm up to sometimes… but overall I’m with @smileypants707 in noting that plain V shapes are suuuper boring.
For example the SF Bliss, I just don’t get why people like it. Plain V.
I want to like the Bliss but it is soooo boring to throw. So boring. Cadence > Bliss.
At least organic has the comfort and chill factor, see everyone’s massive love affair with A-RT; that’s basically all they do is endless iterations of the same organic shape with minor tweaks (and note that it all started with the CLYW Canvas, which was Jensen’s last signature, basically the same thing). And people lose their darn minds over 'em.