I got my mystery bag and it proved me wrong I will never ask this question again it is truly a fun yoyo to throw and almost as smooths as any other yoyo
I donāt see it as novelty. I see it as another tool for another styles of play. Iāve only tried the Superwide once but I like its stability. Pretty nice.
I have the Miracle which is pretty much the same thing, as Studio42 mentioned. I got it as my first metal yo-yo and it was a bit odd at first, yet from my experience it helped me with learning how to land the string more consecutively at first compared to using a slimmer shaped yo-yo.
Is it novelty though, that is a good question. The super wide shape is not my favorite shape for complex string tricks even if it is possible with some adjustment(such as using longer string). For whipping tricks, horizontal, and fast hopping though itās like having training wheels. If you like it, you like it, I suppose.