Im currently using a YYJ Legacy and love it, is smooth, well weighted and a great size. I am looking at upgrading to a metal rimmed YYJ and can’t make a decision. I figure the Dark Magic is a perfect upgrade from the Legacy but I’m not to sure about the Hybrid response. On the other hand i like the dual ring response on the Hitman as well as the width, but am not to sure about the diameter.
Since you do have a Legacy, from Andre, there the Dark Magic. Dark Magic is a bit heavy, sleeps really long, is a little big, but worth it, and has perfect looks. It does come in Hybrid, but it can be un-responsive/responsive. All Andre needed was a KonKave bearing to make it un-responsive. Or shims, or change the o-ring to a silicone o-ring. The Hitman does come in two responses. Hybrid, and double o-ring. Double o-ring is a little less responsive, and is a perfect response. You can also change it to silicone. The Hybrid, is responsive, even when broken in. I have a Hybrid Hitman, and it is responsive. The feel of the Hitman is more of a grinding shape, wider, rounder. The shape of the Dark Magic is more of a thumb grind because of the narrow rims at the end. That, too, is a grinding shape. You will love both, so yes, like Samad said, go with the Hitman.