I’ll tell you what I can about the ones I have -
Fool’s Gold Ava: Absolutely a steal. Not only a great yoyo, but the ano on it is a gorgeous texture. I don’t have any others with the same silkiness.
Summit: AMAZING. Probably not competition fast, but completely smooth and extremely maneuverable. Just the right balance of float and presence.
Arctic Circle: Long spinning and heavy feeling. The combination of width and diameter make it feel like it can fit anywhere but still catch the string. Not my favorite, but that’s just me.
Bear Vs. Man 2: If I was anywhere near competition level, skillwise - I’d be using this. Stable, long spinning and precise. No float, but it still feels really maneuvarable.
Chief: As much love as the Chief gets, I don’t play mine very much. That being said, it’s super stable and spins nice and long. I think mine just feels a bit too light for me. I did try out a different version at PNWR, and am definitely thinking about getting a 7075 edition of it.
Puffin: I love it. It’s real hoppy and great for tight spaces (chopsticks and such) a but not particularly stable. Fun fun fun.
Cliff: Another one I love just for how fun it is. It’s huge, but it’s somehow one of the floatiest throws I own. A joy to play with, however you have to watch out how you catch it. It can easily do some damage to your middle knuckle on a catch.
You also might want to consider the Canvas. You can’t get it on YYE, but if you poke around they are available. In fact, the Raised by Wolves edition is out now, and it’s a good price. Canvas is really a fun throw - very classic, very comfortable.