Listen to the guys who are suggesting Yoyofficer throws. There are simply no better yoyos in their price range in the market in my opinion.
The Musket is a great stable, solid choice.
The Quash is a great mega fast mid size.
Orbis is very light, excellent for zonts and super long spinning.
The imp is silky smooth feeling, light and maneuverable.
The Hatchet 2… Well… an incredible balance of everything.
I own musket and Jaeger
I found musker to be more fast but relax pace of play
Jaeger is totally fun yoyo with easy catch
Found a cheap orbis somewhere and manage to get it somehow
Though this may be $15 dollars over budget, I would definitely go with the RecRev 1st gen. Octave. I have had mine for a year and a half and absolutely love it! If you can find one, it is a great choice!