Let’s stick to your choices. I will confuse things later.
One of the first things you need to keep in mind is how important personal preferences are for the enjoyment of a yoyo. You mentioned a lot of people dislike the SuperNova. I am in that group of people. Is the SuperNova bad? Nope, not in the least. The only thing you can determine from my saying I dislike the SuperNova is that I flat out state that it doesn’t blend well with my primary preferences, and didn’t fit in well with my generous tolerances. At the same time, this is a regular selling yoyo with lots of users who enjoy it. Make sure you take any dislikes and “Bad reviews” with the proverbial “grain of salt”. You have to read reviews and suggestions and then process that information to see how it applies for you. I myself was interested in trying a SuperNova. Someone put it in my hand at Nationals 2012 so they could try a One Drop, and I was just simply not enjoying the SuperNova. That’s how it goes sometimes. Some people try my One Drop yoyos and CLYW’s and some have discovered “no, I didn’t like that one”, and thus I’ve saved them from making a bad purchase.
While there are a lot of YYF’s that I don’t like, there’s plenty more that I do like.
So, onto some models that you have listed:
The Shutter will get your job done. It’s more 1A oriented though.
The dv888 is another yoyo that doesn’t mesh well with me. It’s good, there’s nothing wrong with it, I just find it to be bland, plays heavy and is nothing all that special. The small size doesn’t lend itself for your 5A desires.
The AYCE, Cupcake and Poo I have not tried, so no opinion.
So, under $100 and you want 1A/5A performance…
Burnside and the new(er) Chik. Both under $100 and similar shape to the SuperNova.
The YYF Destiny is around $55 or so, but it’s a touch small, but it’s excellent at 5A and 1A, but designed for 1A. If you want bigger, get the SFX.
Another option might be the Duncan Strix.
If you’re after “let’s be cheap”, well, there’s some fantastic plastics that are good multi-style performers:
Adegle PSG and/or PSG Gem is great for 1A, 3A and 5A and at under $15… wow.
Classic with upgrades is also good for 1A, 3A and 5A. The Surge seems good for 1A and 5A.
The YYF Stackless Grind Machine is fun, and seems good for 1A and 5A, but I wouldn’t use it for 3A only due to the shape.
I find the ALpha Crash to be more 1A oriented, but still good at 3A and 5A. The new Speedaholid looks promising for 1A/3A/5A as well.