I have played most of the suggested throws and while I prefer full size throws, monkeyfist. It fits all your wants and is available new. There is a good reason the Spin Dynamic stuff doesn’t show up second hand very often. Good luck on your choosing.
Yep, Monkey Fists are amazing.
Yay! Let’s quote all the pictures!!
But on a more serious note, the Stargazer is an amazingly good choice. I find it to be more mid-sized though.
Ooooohhh, Again! Again!
I disagree with that last statement.
While I love my Puffin, I have to agree.
Puffin’s really fun to throw; however, if you really want “undersized” I wouldn’t have it on this list. Maybe it’s a bit smaller than some, but it doesn’t seem at all undersized to me. Even the Gnarwhal isn’t really “undersized” in my opinion (53.x mm as I recall) but it is smaller than the Puffin.
Dietz. Nuff said. No in all seriousness, I like the dietz because it is very fast, smooth, and stable. Don’t like the weight (like me?) pop in another set of side effects. Code 1 side effects are perfect for me, so experiment and see what you like!
So have you chosen yet?