This is really a tough choice for me. The format c is by far the best yoyo I’ve handled. I got a yyr butcher and it feels … weird in my hand . Don’t like the feel of it too much. Performance wise, does the messiah perform better? because I might trade my format c for it.
If you’re asking which one’s better performing, probably the Format:C. If you’re asking which one you will like more, nobody can tell you that 
You may like the play of the Format:C better, but I doubt that it’s better performing then the Butcher.
The Format C can spin for like 3 minutes easy. The butcher can barely spin for a minute 
I even try cleaning the bearing seat and what not but still the same
This should not be the case, the butcher should spin way longer than that.
I just got 7 minutes on my Butcher
I can get more then 1 minute on a YYF ONE 
what how
You’d be hard pressed to find more different yoyos… Also the Mr. Butcher is well known for being the YYR most UNlike other YYR’s so don’t use that as a baseline.
If the Format C is the best yoyo you’ve used then keep it. I can tell you that the Messiah is a great undersized yoyo, one of the best. However, unless you’re keen on getting an undersized yoyo I wouldn’t trade.
This is true. The Messiah is great but it is undersized and on the solid side. I love it but it isn’t exactly comparable to the Format C. Personally I’d go Messiah, but that shouldn’t mean much to you and your choice.