Henry’s Lizard from John Narum.
VERY first: YYF F.A.S.T. 201 from Wal*Mart.
First yo-yo that I actually used: YYJ Kickside from Dazzling Dave.
F.A.S.T 201 was my first i got through split the atom then got a dark magic.
Speed bettle.
FHZ
Black Kickside
Fast 201 enough said
It was one of those Coca-Cola, Fanta or Sprite yoyos in the 90’s. My brother had old Russell Coca-Cola yoyo from the late 80’s/early 90’s and I think it was my first touch with a yoyo. Still got it 
EDIT:
Just took a picture of it:
When I first started yoyoing back when I was about 6: a dollar store yoyo.
When I restarted at age 10 but never caught on: a FAST 201
On March 1st 2009 (I consider this my actual beginning): YYJ Speeder.
yomega fireball
Duncan Imperial
duncan freehand and also wondering whats a good second yoyo
Hitman all the way!
booo yaaa
Duncan Mosquito
A yellow B C Spitfire (old logo) … I didn’t know what I purchased I just saw a cool looking wooden yoyo. I loved it and played it so much it broke it in half at the axle. For some stupid reason I never replaced it until just a few days ago. Now I have 6 of them 5 put away for the future and going to order more.
I feel your pain ED. My first yo-yo was an Humming bird, natural in color Beautiful. But like all well played wood yo-yos it broke in half and I have never been able to replace it. Any one have one lying around please drop me a line.
Not exactly my first yoyo, but I got back into yoyo’s after picking up and Duncan speed beetle from toys r us… Years ago during High School I had this really nice wooden yo-yo, can no longer remember the name of that one though.