Right now my favorite is the Atmos Butterball. I can’t say that I have had it long enough for it to be my favorite of all time though. The yoyo that I always go back to is the OG Edge. I like the basic shape and size. Nothing fancy just consistency and good play. I think the most important factor for me enjoying a yoyo is the response. Even a heavy yoyo that doesn’t “thunk” when it reaches the bottom of the string is fun.
Do prefer the C bearing or D bearing version of the 5050?
I have a D bearing 5050 and I love it. Absolutely in my top 5 yoyos of all time.