I do not own a puffin or AC but I have had plenty of time to try each and I have owned 4 chiefs.
The Chief is definitly the best and then the AC and last is the Puffin. From the looks of the puffin I knew it would not perform. It didn’t have enough spin time for me and it just (for me) didn’t live up to the hype I knew would be attached to it just because it is a CLYW.
It hasn’t even been a week so the “new” factor is still in play at the moment for all the puffin owners. I got to try one and had a chance to trade for one and I didn’t take it. I want pure performance in a throw and it didn’t deliver.
In comparison to the AC and Chief the puffin was lighter than the AC witch I think is just to bulky feeling and it is faster than the AC. Stability is good but the lackluster spin time just left me wanting more in this yoyo. I comes nowhere near the chief in playability for sure.
In my opinion the puffin is a overpriced yoyo that doesn’t perform just like the canvas. I absolutly love CLYW yoyos, I have 7 at the moment and they are amazing but I will not sugar coat a yoyo that does not impress me.
Hope I wasn’t too harsh but I am just giving my account on the yoyo.