All 3 are awesome throws for 1A. I would look @ what specs you like in a yoyo and go w/ that. The DM and New Breed are large YoYo’s and the Atmosphere is more undersized. they are all kind of on the heavy side, ect ect.
The New Breed is by far the lightest one of the bunch, so if you want something light go for that. If you want something small go for the Atmosphere. If you want something big you have to choose between the other two. The Dark Magic has some more rim-weight that the New Breed.
The shapes aren’t that different. Size and weight is the real deciding factors here.
Just so you know, having multiple accounts is against the rules of the forum. If you wanted a name change, you should have asked a moderator or Andre (yoyoexpert).
It’s totally up to you. If you need to, flip a coin or roll a die or something. You’ll end up with a good yoyo, and whatever you get will help you start to figure out your preferences.