I would suggest the Surge, Alpha Crash, or Trigger.
I got started on unresponsive with the Surge. It can really take a beating (I’ve dropped it on concrete 4-5 times). It’s just a very good yoyo.
I’ve also heard a lot of really good stuff about the Trigger and Alpha crash so I plan on getting those at some point.
To OP: Stay away from triggers, the rims will break. It plays really nicely, but IT WILL happen at some point. The surge is a good bet, the alpha crash is also amazing. I vote surge (GET SHIMS WITH IT) or alpha crash.
Thanks for the tip on the Trigger. The Alpha Crash looks interesting, I’ll probably end up trying it out in a couple weeks. I went ahead and got an Asteroid for the time being. I’ll be getting the ONEstar and the Alpha Crash probably at the same time.
I never understand all the Trigger hate. Really, what are you guys doing to these things to break them so easily? Slamming them forcefully on concrete? I have a Trigger that used to belong to JD himself, that was used extensively to test the design, which since I got it from JD months ago is played very regularly since it is my FAVORITE plastic out. It has hit the deck a few times, and still smooth and no breaks. a couple times with some decent force. I really just don’t get how people slam them into the ground and then complain that something is wrong.