I just have no idea just wanna know what you guys think?
Depends on what you are looking for. For me the Baldwin gives more of the old fixed axle feel, while the Lovejoy plays almost like a bearing yoyo. Often, I have to bind the Lovejoy to get it to return.
I haven’t tried a Lovejoy yet, but I can tell you the Baldwin is not a long sleeping wood. It’s a pure delight but pretty light and well suited for stalls.