$90-100 on the BvM2 imo. I’ve seen 2 MIB Clareview BvM2s sold for $100 recently which I thought was a really fair price, actually sorta wish I bought one of them. I personally don’t much care if something has a tiny scuff that I can’t feel but some people do so that brings it down a few bucks.
BvM2 seems to have a popular following as a player but for whatever reason they don’t seem to go for a ton on the BST compared to some other models.
I’m glad you enjoy it and I’m glad you think it plays like $90+. Doesn’t change the fact that it’s a $60 retail yoyo that is sitting on the shelves. As a rough comparison, I think the Mutant DNA is a really fun and unique throw. I believe it was $140 retail and is now discontinued and unavailable in stores (and never had to be discounted). Unfortunately nobody is knocking down the doors to my BST to buy mine.
Pretty sure the Hatrick has a bigger following than the Essence but I don’t think either is in terribly high demand. I had an unengraved grey/blue Hatrick and Essence, both first run and mint and they weren’t easy to sell/trade and they were both quite rare. I traded my Essence to the right person for something I ended up getting about $100 out of (after a couple more trades, bye bye shipping costs) and sold my Hatrick for $90-100 as I recall.
Pretty much what modman said imo, $70-80ish for a mint one in general seems reasonable, $100ish if there’s something special about it.
MIB Smear gully Skywalker and NIB (unknown colorway, one ding) Skywalker:
I’m on the recieving end of a trade and I don’t know which one to pick. I’ll probably keep it for a while but I want to get the one that’ll be easier to trade, thanks guys!