I went with the left…but they are definitely both nice. I agree like Burdger that this one is both splash difference and engraving so, if engravings were swapped, for a lot of people the vote might differ. I think that holds true for me too. Right is more my style, but I think the engraving made me go with the left.
I definitely like them better than the silver, but I am a bit curious how black would look instead. I’m definitely happy with the red though, looks pretty nice this way and has more of a “YoyoExpert” look too.