So I’m in middle school and 5a is just okay for me but I’m just curious if it is okay for me to make more counterweights. (Like 50) I plan to sell them later on the BST but could Duncan sue me?
I really don’t know if you could do that or not. Duncan might be mad. But if you call them something else (which would be a bit dishonest) you might be fine.
Even if you’re making a smaller run, Duncan won’t let you sell them. Duncan is fine with you making counterweights for personal use, but not selling them.
I got my stuff deleted when I sold a few. Thats when the Admins decided to ban it from the forums.
Dead end I suppose…
What are you making? Waspnests?
Acrylic Pressured Counterweights. I will post a pic asap… Still can’t sell them though
Unfortunately, the US patent duncan owns on a small object with a hole in it is holding back 5A, since other brands can’t promote it unless they want to pay boo-koo bucks (YoYoJam’s Takeshi Die is $5).
2020 seems pretty far away, too.
It’s really annoying. Yoyfactory even has to cut out their 5a stuff in their vids. -.-
Takeshi Matsuura is WORLD CHAMPION IN 5A, yet Yoyojam barely got to sell counterweights.
Ughhhh I guess they think they have some power over yoyoing now…
Pull a Yoyofactory and call them Spin-Top Buttons. Or do something like make them and don’t drill a hole through them, instead, say something like, these are very cool whatevers, and if you want, I can drill a hole through it for your keychain or something lol Where there’s a will, there’s a way around any contract
Call them weights that counter.
I’m liking yoyospirit’s idea. I’d love a counterweight sized keyring
That is like what I have!
Nope. Can’t sell them, no matter what you call them. Sorry.
Here’s the patent:
The very general wording seems to make it very inclusive. You could sell them as other things, but the moment you people start using them as counterweights on anything but a 4A yoyo you could be sued.
You could ‘give’ them away and take donations
No you can’t.
Seriously, all of you people who don’t understand patent law should probably stop giving legal advice to people who are looking for a way to get around my patent. For a number of reasons:
- You’re wrong.
- I’m RIGHT HERE. I see all of this stuff.
- So do people from Duncan.
So let’s start a new habit, shall we? When someone new pops up, as they inevitably will every few months, and says “I have an idea to make some counterweight, would you guys buy them?” how about we all just agree to say “Actually, you can’t sell counterweights unless you license the patent from Duncan. But you can make them for your own personal use. Post pictures, we’d all like to see them when you’re done.”
Yeah? Let’s just do that.
I can’t stop laughing at this…well played good sir. doffing my hat
Regarding the patent, I have a question. Does the patent cover sales, say, between buddies or something? Like, if a buddy of mine made a CW and I gave him 5 bucks for it, would that be illegal practice?
Soooo…how about as good luck charms