If I had three from the list, I wouldn’t be so ashamed, but alas I have four. And yes that would ironically be #4 that brings me my shame. Maybe all just part of the journey to be the best - “Gateway Throws”
I have one of these. They’re basically a Raider with a transaxle. They’re actually a fairly good looper. I also have one that I made into a fixed axle with a BC wood sleeve. Again, a fair looper.
I have the MAGICYOYO V3. It was my first “new” yoyo once I got back into the hobby. I can’t say I throw it much anymore, but it got me where I needed it to get me
The yo-yo’s marketed towards kids and beginners, and I doubt most of them care about factors like anodizing thickness.
It seems like you’re viewing it through the eyes of an adult collector, and not through the view of its target audience.
I’m sure there are other cheap beginner yo-yos that have “thicker anodizing”, but honestly, the people that nitpick so closely about factors like aluminum grade and anodizing type are probably mostly adult collectors, most of which wouldn’t touch a magicyoyo with a 20 foot pole.
I exclusively used a magicyoyo n11 for the first year and a half of my yoyoing, and it got me to a pretty good level of skill, single-handedly. Which is exactly what it’s designed to do. As a kid, I just loved putting in and taking out the weight rings, which is a neat touch. It makes kids feel like they’re changing up their options, and it’s fun to introduce the idea of rim weight.
I still throw mine sometimes, (and it’s still smoother than any of my one drops by the way) to this day. Also it’s still fun as heck.
Are there better options out there for $15 that might have thicker anodizing or something? Maybe. Do I think this yo-yo deserves 2 stars? No.