Feeling bummed

Back in August I was able to get my hands on a dead stock 08 888 that was completely raw and unfinished.

I had always wanted to get my hands on a nice 08, and being raw it felt like a good opportunity to finally get some custom ano done, something I’ve wanted ever since I was a kid looking at Jason Wong Zero’s work.

Anyways, this Friday I finally got it back from being tumbled and ano’d and this is the result:

I had some suspicion that it hadn’t turned out too great when the anodizer had told me it had been mailed back but they hadn’t taken any pictures of the final result… This pitting (these are not ano flaws, they’re literally mini craters) is apparently the result of forgetting that the yoyo is 7075 and assuming that it’s 6061 without double checking with me.

I’ve been trying to feel positive about it but it’s starting to sink in that I ruined a yoyo that I won’t be able to easily replace and now I’m feeling pretty down about it. Obviously I know b-grades are a thing and not to expect perfection from a one off, but I’ve never seen ano defects this bad in any yoyo for sale.

I know that in the grand scheme of things this isn’t the end of the world, I just think I got a bit ahead of myself with expectations waiting to get this back and am making this post to vent because I don’t have anyone to talk to in real like who would understand.

14 Likes

Awwwe I’m so dorry to hear that..Can nothing be done at all? :frowning:

2 Likes

Are you sure the issue was assuming it was 6061. It seems odd that the harder 7075 aluminum would cause pitting. Did the anodizer tell you this?

Anyway, I’m sorry to hear this! I’m sure it was very disappointing!

4 Likes

I think it would need pretty extensive sanding which could cause other issues, but being the original finish is part of what made having this done as a custom so cool to me, because the yoyo didn’t need to be damaged/altered to remove old ano.

>I wish I knew it was a 7075 aluminum before I started it could’ve prevented some of the pitting.

This is what I was told before I saw the yoyo, and it bothers me because it feels like he’s trying to shift the blame onto me for not telling him. First of all I did make sure to mention it, but secondly even if I didn’t why would the alloy be assumed if it matters this much?

4 Likes

Who anoed it?

I also had a custom ano done by someone with not much experience with yoyos that didnt go according to plan. The custom was a bit elaborate so they kept going ham on polishing the yoyo and stripping it one too many times and the bearing seat is loose as hell now​:sob:

Gotta be careful who we trust and have to assume the yoyo can be ruined.

2 Likes

I’ll just say they definitely have experience with yoyos.

3 Likes

What if you blasted it again better. You would have to strip it and anodize again. But it might hide all of those flaws better if it done better. Also another idea is to have it powder coated. May not be perfect but it’s worth a shot.

1 Like

Umm… what the ■■■■? This is pretty egregious. Why are we trying to protect the reputation of someone who very clearly messed up here? There aren’t many anodizers out there with yoyo experience… this narrows it down quite a bit. Who is it so no one else makes the same mistake? Hoping this was free of charge or else I’d be hitting my bank up for a chargeback.

10 Likes

This is vile, what the heck??? This is an injustice

4 Likes

I hope they have you a full refund as an apology for messing it up so badly, which is entirely on them. They could’ve either written down what alloy it was, or just asked you. Their failure to do so is really poor communication on their part. Something so scarce should be treated with utmost care; it’s not like you can just whip up another one.

2 Likes

That’s really crappy and I would definitely get a refund or chargeback unless you signed something meaning they are not liable but I’m not sure of details but yeah it’s in rough condition.

Has the anno and pitting caused it to vibe at all I’m wondering if it can be sanded. I would not accept that

2 Likes

I guess I’m non confrontational, but fair point… It was BT. Like I said I had high hopes for this.

I paid $25 + round trip shipping for him to do his choice of colourway because I’m honestly not picky and just wanted something cool (I was thinking of it like having a tattoo artist choose the design), so I’m not really concerned about the money I gave him. I really just feel upset about the yoyo.

10 Likes

I had very similar issues with gruntbull. I had them anodize an 888 a couple years ago and it turned out pretty similar. I did a whole write up on all the issues on here.

3 Likes

I literally just shipped 100 raw yo-yos to BT. At least they were 6061? That doesn’t make me less nervous now ha.so sorry this happened

5 Likes

I don’t anodize so I have no real experience, but I wonder if the quality of the metal itself has anything to do with it. I don’t have pics on hand, but when I stripped several yoyos years ago, some of the cheaper amazon specials pitted like this, while some of the more name brand stuff was fine. There was also severe differences with how long I needed to leave the solution on there for; the cheaper amazon yoyos lost their ano super quickly (almost instantaneous) while others needed a few minutes to soak. Some of the cheaper throws ended up being unusable after because they literally felt like sandpaper afterwards.

FWIW, i still think it looks great.

4 Likes

I know that 7075 is more difficult to anodize which is why I made sure to mention it. In my opinion the aluminum feels just as high quality as my Onedrops, these old YYF yoyos feel worlds better than their new stuff quality wise.

7075 is alloyed with zing, magnesium, and copper while 6061 is magnesium and silicon, so I assume this pitting issue is because of some chemical interaction that needs to be taken into account.

1 Like

A wise man once said…

“If I ain’t broke, don’t fix it.”

4 Likes

Yeah, I’m not sure, especially since yours was raw to begin with so he wouldn’t have needed to strip it. I guess I’m just surprised that it pitted, especially being 7075; and I agree the older YYF stuff feels a lot more premium of material. It could be me being crazy but my OG Genesis and Catalyst feel a lot different than some of the more modern stuff I had from them.

I do think timeframe is important, that’s what I noticed about the stripping and pitting/harsh finish afterwards. I left some of the throws unattended for 5-10 mins and that’s when I noticed the issues. The next batch I stripped I paid closer attention/monitored and noticed some of the cheaper stuff only needed 30s-1min to strip while some of the other throws needed that full 5-10 minutes to cut through to the deep anodization in the pores.

3 Likes

I understand your feelings about the outcome. The gap between what anyone would reasonably expect is clear.

Still, it doesn’t look terrible to me. Just unusual. How does it play?

2 Likes