Cake’s String Reviews

I think Cake did well to point out in the OP that these are just opinions. String preferences are super personal somehow. I definitely disagree with Cake about some of the reviews and also strongly agree about others. No ones reviews should be considered as holy truth and 99% of people know that. It is hard to try all the strings out there and it’s cool that Cake is out here trying to help people get a sense for different strings. Time and time again cake acknowledges that her reviews, like all reviews, are subjective and has kinda gone out of her way to highlight that.

I don’t know…just wanted to share my thoughts.

12 Likes

I mean, everyone knows Throw-Yo Ropes are the best there is :wink:

Seriously, though. When I read @theendofcake’s reviews I tend to focus more on the words than the numbers. She’s got a way of explaining things that narrows down what’s important to me about a string when it comes to how I play.

She has a system, and sticks to it. It’s an extremely good quality for a reviewer to have!

11 Likes

oh yeah 100% get more Rope, i know i memed on it but there’s genuinely nothing like it

5 Likes

Throw yo Rope is absurd. I love it. It might actually work better on a spin top than a regular unresponsive yoyo to be honest but in a responsive it’s a neat experience,

2 Likes

Also I’ve said it enough times I really don’t see why I’m saying it again. But I’m OCD and repeat myself often so why not.

I love cakes reviews but I am also very aware how cake plays and what is valued in a string is very different from me and the scoring system isn’t very important compared to what is in the word written about the string.

Also my biggest regret is how some of the best reviewed string on the list isn’t even available anymore.

2 Likes

Totally! And what I absolutely love about this is Mark did the review?
I really appreciate someone stating the negatives. I’ve been waiting for it because I’m aware of it all lol but no one has ever said it.
String choice 1000000% comes down to player preference. Some people don’t like the initial gritty feel of trilobal, I personally won’t play anything if it has even 1 wrap of nylon in it.
I’m going to link this if people ask for more details. Maybe I can get that on the website too.
Becaus honestly when people ask I don’t even know what to say I’m just like yeah, it last forever and you have to break it in for like a week and once it’s past the crunchy phase it’s nice and soft and it’s fast. And then that’s not enough info haha.

5 Likes

yeah! mark contacted me and asked if he could send along some fox tails for review bc he loved them and wanted to see what i thought, so i agreed, got them in, and played with it for an hour and a half from new. i still have some on me, maybe ill wash them and rereview them when i have the time. i’m proud of what i do, and im so happy to have the support of everyone here!

DM me if you need help with anything! always happy to help

3 Likes

I think the inclusion of terminology like “Personal thickness feel”, “Whip feel”, etc makes it pretty clear Cake’s rating system is about personal preference. Even if you were to skip all the writing (and why would you do that, it’s the best part!) and just look at the score, the subjectivity is hardly hidden.

4 Likes

As stated, this isnt a end all/be all.

I actually find the scoring helpful. While a string may get a lower score in one area, that may be exactly what I am looking for in a string.

Might not score high for Cake, but there is enough description to let me know it could score high for Me.

5 Likes

this is 100% my primary objective, hope i never stray from it

3 Likes

Yeah, reviewing anything subjective is tricky and I think this is as good as a system as you can get with reviews such as these. Very helpful all around though. Overwhelming at first but I tend to get ahead of myself. It’s a great one stop thread to get more info on strings you may be interested in.

I like the Cake review, I think she does a great job and I agree with everyone praising her, no one does that around so its a great service.

The only thing I wanted to pointed out from a bit (hope without get killed) is not about the rating, I can understand it but about she play the string for only 1 and a half hour or similar.

I think most of the strings I play and love give the best after 4/5 hours of playing when the bounciness is gone and them thin out a bit, I play quite hardcore and I like to mistreat the strings and always I notice how much strings are nice after a bit of worn out.

Even for my videos I like to use “used” string at least 5 hours of play behind them and usually I noticed how much better they keep the tension (in general all of them).

If I can give my poor 2 cents to her I would say maybe to play muuuch longer with them before the review at least 15 hours, only like that I think a person can have a complete view of a string, it goes from new to the peak and then exhausting but is a full cicle

Said that I encourage Cake to do what she doing and have fun :yo-yo:

8 Likes

you’re very right on this, that’s one of the biggest flaws. i was thinking about this and actually attempted it with some whiteout alphaline, but i think my limit is about 3 hours before i can’t use it based on texture or tension holding. even if both of those qualities get better with time, im too weak to get past the hurdle :pensive: i have pretty moist hands and live in a humid environment, which can affect the life of the string too. i dont think im capable of having a complete view of string (nor do I really want to), so instead i tackle the one to one and half hours I have with it to the best of my ability :smiling_face:

5 Likes

Someone in a dry climate should start a 5-hour string reviews thread using the same criteria to compliment Cake’s reviews.

4 Likes

sweet ok! You both used them! That makes me happy! Because I make so few and want everyone to try them lol.

3 Likes

back on it!

HKMT Ayumu || A- (90/100)


I did NOT expect this to be an A, mainly because im not a fan of the worn feel near the end, but WOW

First impressions, its loosely wound and slightly soft, where the threads kind of blend into each other to create a nice, slight plush. It doesn’t lose its softness at all by 30 minutes, and it always has a subtle stiffness to it. Binds are amazing and about normal thickness, bit less than OT Normal i think? Slacks are light, fluffy, very open, and full of flight while simultaneously maintaining a presence in the hands and when making contact. Whips aren’t fast by any means, but more controlled. Both of these performance feels are the kind that compliments technical skill very well, but don’t supplement any skill. Maybe the white color of the string is helping me, but the string seems like a carefully crafted blank easel for you to make your own creative tricks. Very artsy! I’m a HUGE fan.

While the string starts feeling a little dirty and slightly rougher by the hour (that’s the worn in feel), the performance stays the same. The tension barely builds up and the consistency is perfection. Being able to pull off minimal performance change on white polyester string is very impressive. This is a string with no bells and whistles, just quality polyester made to fit you personally. If you love the worn string feel, this is that and More. Amazing stuff. Stats below.

Durability 30 min (5)
Durability 1 hr (4) aging like fine wine
Personal Thickness Feel (5)
Whip Feel Break-In (4)
Whip Feel 1 hr (4.5)
Slack Feel Break-In (4.5)
Slack Feel 1 hr (4.5)
Tension Hold over 1 hour overall (4.5)
Softness during break-in (4)
Overall consistency over 1 hour (5)
Total: 45 x 2 = 90, 90 = A- graded based on letter system (A: 100-90, B: 89-80, C: 79-70, D: 69-60, F: 60<)

15 Likes

last review before worlds! i’ll be there, come say hi :people_hugging:

HKMT Hajime || B- (80/100)

This string is fairly rough, with a fat thickness to it that doesn’t really overdo itself. The loose wind and tactile feel of the twists in the string get lost when you play, so it ends up feeling like a straight roughness (which gets more rough when broken in). The slacks feel amazing, very open and solid with a bit of heft and speed that doesn’t feel like it’s hand-holding you. Whips are moderately fast for 100% polyester and just feels good combined with the string weight.

It ages slower than bulk poly, and by the hour it plays very close to how it felt brand new, besides more roughness and ever so slight fraying. Because of how minimal performance changed, the durability ranking is quite high. The tension holding is fantastic too, which is another mark of high quality. Lastly, my only complaint with the consistency of the string is how loose the slack can feel sometime. I have a feeling it’s a skill issue on my end, and it doesn’t actively hinder any performance, so I’m still viewing it positively. The score would be so much higher if it wasn’t for the comfort factor, so sorry. Overall amazing string, and I’m so happy to see that HKMT never disappoints. I have no clue how they don’t make meh strings, but i’m happy they don’t. If you can, try it out. $15 for 20 of them is a solid price. Stats below!

Durability 30 min (4.5)
Durability 1 hr (4.5)
Personal Thickness Feel (2.5)
Whip Feel Break-In (4.5)
Whip Feel 1 hr (4.5)
Slack Feel Break-In (5)
Slack Feel 1 hr (4.5)
Tension Hold over 1 hour overall (4)
Softness during break-in (1.5)
Overall consistency over 1 hour (4.5)
Total: 40 x 2 = 80, 80 = B- graded based on letter system (A: 100-90, B: 89-80, C: 79-70, D: 69-60, F: 60<)

10 Likes

happy saturday, nothing to report because of worlds. go watch the stream!!!

10 Likes

posting this early to help people get this string as cheap as possible, everyone deserves to try it.

Canopy Rope || A (94/100)


A bit of an explanation for this is needed. I’ve been REALLY wanting to try this ever since it was announced, as seen here.
image
I saw that it was using “a blend of string adapted from [Sochi’s] Phoenix line”, as said on the Canopy Collection Website. Phoenix String also “combines Alphaline Technology with SOCHI’s Pro Prostring Blend” as said on the YYE page for it. Now, i have a few questions:

  • Whats Alphaline Technology ?
  • What’s Prostring Blend?
  • If the Canopy blend is from Phoenix String and the Phoenix blend is Pro Prostring Blend (weird name), is it really based off of Phoenix string? Wouldn’t it be based off of Prostring instead?

I have no answers for these (yet), but with all that being said, i was excited nonetheless since Phoenix String is one of my favorites. I was sad they wouldn’t have them at Worlds, but turns out my Canopy AL came with one string of Rope, and after almost losing it among a sea of Alphaline Whiteout, the review is now here.

This is SOFT, maybe a bit too soft for me when it starts out. After about 4-5 minutes though, the softness goes from too much to right in the Goldilocks Zone of softness, which is stunning. I didn’t think Alphaline Whiteout could be improved on, but here it is. The string has about an average wind with a feel that perfectly blends the feeling of the strands on your fingers. Early on, slacks and whips were very fast, maybe around OT levels, but with a bit of give in the solidity that’s also present in Phoenix String and SLACKiES. Fatter string pulls this off slightly better if i’m remembering correctly. I couldn’t really narrow down the weight of the slack because, to be honest, that’s one of the things im the worst at. The string lost the initial stretchiness and started to really show the worn fuzzies around the 30 minute mark. I heard that these fuzzies can activate the response earlier and it may be a placebo effect, but the age didn’t impact binds as much as I thought it would. I felt a bit of tighter binds, maybe by a .5 score, thicker than Phoenix String. Near the hour, the string plateaued exactly where it was at the 30 minute mark. The only difference is that tension holding became ever so slightly worse and whips felt a bit slower, but all of those aren’t observations that can be set in stone.

Compared to other strings I’ve used, the tension wasn’t bad at all, which was my main concern. Consistency was off the charts, as the only variables in how the string behaved felt like it came from me or the tension. Everything else felt the same, which is an amazing mark for the durability of this string. The slacks and whips throughout the hour were definitely on the assisting side because of the speed, but everything else like weight, shape, etc. didn’t carry me too much to be called an assist or a crutch. I heard it gets softer after some more hours, so look forward to that too!

Overall, this is outstanding and really promising from a brand as new as Canopy. I’ll put my money where my mouth is and buy a 200 pack after this, i feel like I’ll stick with this for a while. Definitely worth the $25 for how long they can last and still feel like new. I highly recommend this for fans of the “broken in” feel that want a faster paced string, fans of Alphaline, and fans of Phoenix String. Stats below!

Durability 30 min (4)
Durability 1 hr (4.5)
Personal Thickness Feel (5)
Whip Feel Break-In (5)
Whip Feel 1 hr (4.5)
Slack Feel Break-In (4.5)
Slack Feel 1 hr (4.5)
Tension Hold over 1 hour overall (4)
Softness during break-in (6)
Overall consistency over 1 hour (5)
Total: 47 x 2 = 94, 94 = A graded based on letter system (A: 100-90, B: 89-80, C: 79-70, D: 69-60, F: 60<)

go buy some, as the sale ends tomorrow at midnight. see yall in a week and a half

18 Likes

long day today, late post

MarkMont Nylon Nylon Nylon (Fat) || D (66/100)

Honesty is always the #1 quality in reviews, and honestly, I can’t use this. The string is reallly soft and plush, but it’s so bouncy that it’s harder to do my lacerations and hooks. Whips are super inconsistent because of the stretch and speed when the string goes limp, but slacks are actually pretty good! I can’t feel much of the slack (maybe because of the plush), but the string is light and a bit lagging behind. This is paired by its speed in tension tricks, which brings a little bit of the floppiness back in due to the stretch. Durability is always amazing for nylon, and this is no exception. This’ll last you for a WHILE, if you even want to after the first 15 minutes.

I don’t know what thickness this is, but I’m assuming it’s fat. I heard that regular thickness Nylonx3 is almost unplayable because of the thinness, so be aware for that. If your collection is small and you’re a fan of the chill vibe of a 100% nylon string, this is an average one out of the many boutiques out there. Nothing too special about this, sorry to say. The notable features of the slower slacks and great thickness on binds is overshadowed by the Curse of Nylon and its inconsistencies, so im pretty ambivalent on this personally. If it sounds like you’re style, go for it! The quality of MarkMont is always nice to see. Stats below.

Durability 30 min (5)
Durability 1 hr (5)
Personal Thickness Feel (3.5)
Whip Feel Break-In (2) fast
Whip Feel 1 hr (3) i get it now
Slack Feel Break-In (3) fast!!
Slack Feel 1 hr (3)
Tension Hold over 1 hour overall (2)
Softness during break-in (4.5)
Overall consistency over 1 hour (2.5)
Total: 33.5 x 2 = 67, 67 = D graded based on letter system (A: 100-90, B: 89-80, C: 79-70, D: 69-60, F: 60<)

12 Likes