Hello everyone! This is my first topic and first poll, so if I put this in the wrong category, please feel free to move it! So, down to business. I made a couple Designs and i was wondering which of these designs were most appealing to the community. That’s you guys! I will bump this category from time to time. Just to bring it back to life!
http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7402/11228324554_3766629fab_c.jpg
Yoyos by shapegsx, on Flickr
Please feel free to give some constructive criticism!
I don’t know much.
All your designs appear to be center heavy.
I do like your general presentation though. I can actually relate to that.
I think design c would be best if you thinned the walls and put more weight on the rims.
I don’t know anything about weight distribution but I would happily mess with any one of those designs.
D looks like it’ll mess you up if you don’t catch it right. A looks like something I’d like to try.
design A would certainly be an interesting player… those edges look rather sharp though…
Yeah, I’ll definitely have thinner walls. This is just the design stage. I’ll, literally, smooth out the edges! 
P.S. Design b has a lateral cap
Yeah, I like design C, but I’ve seen it to many times. I try to make some of the yo-yos unique in a way. I made these with folded up sticky notes on the floor at 6:00 a.m. So I wasn’t exactly thinking about that 
We’ll it seems E is in the lead!
E would certainly be a menace to the Starship Enterprise.
It certainly has been done before, and I would like to see something new, so I change my vote to a or b. Anyways these are great so far, keep it up!
I totally appreciate the CAD-free approach.
Lol, I don’t even know how to use cad. Sometimes I use Google Sketch Up, but I can barely even use that!
Ok, so I’ve got the winning design, I combined all the elements that people liked and I mixed A, B, and E
What would be a good size. I will change the poll so you can choose. Post in the comment, board… Thing. ??? 
The perfect spot IMO is 56 by 43,
A good full sized, wide enough throw.
Why no love for B? with good weight distribution that profile would be an awesome player.
Anyway, have a plan to do CAD on them? I can help you with CAD.
Actually, I don’t need CAD. I’m sending it off to someone to do it. I’m clueless with stuff like that, I’ve tried it and failed, miserably. 
B.U.M.P it up!
I think u need to make some accurate drawings to get the real feedback u need. We need to be looking at CAD drawings or something like that. Sticky notes just doesn’t cut it.