So, after doing a bit of research I got the Asteroid, got it in, and it’s super wobbly. Then, I noticed that it was extremely loose, you had to get it uncomfortably tight to stay in place. Here’s the axle. Might be hard to see, but the threads at the end are bent.
Brought in the bent one and got a 4 pack of 'em, works great, no longer have the weird tightness problem. The axle itself wasn’t loose, it was like it refused to tighten at all once it got to a point and just hung there. But as I said, fixed now.