Is the obsession with smoothness/vibe hurting yoyo design?

This is the intent of the original post restated. And I too would love to hear the OD team’s opinion, as well as the @crackout from ILYY.

Perhaps some of the best designs have been shelved in fear of how the community would react to a little vibe.

4 Likes

Japan Tech Lapua. They released this $400 Titanium yo-yo, despite it having more than the normal acceptable vibe, and I haven’t heard anything but positive feedback on it. It is an amazing performer. Still wish I grabbed one for myself, but didn’t have the spare funds at the time.

6 Likes

Here’s a mock up of the bronze(gall proof) replaceable bearing post I’ve been “working on” for -a few years-, it could lead to great things…

18 Likes

Cool idea. Would that require a thinner axle?

2 Likes

I’ve built it with the existing axle(M4X.7) and have had zero issues. I am considering going down one size though, and testing further.

9 Likes

That’s cool they can “get away with it”, but we cannot. The two biggest stresses running this business by far for us are:

  1. Anodizing
  2. Vibe

To avoid having vibey yoyos in the world, we won’t even sell them as b-grades. We only b-grade for visual flaws.

11 Likes

The point I was trying to make is that if it performs well enough people will accept a little imperfection.

4 Likes

I think this can depend on the brand. I may be wrong, but I think of smoothness as a big part of the One Drop brand. Maybe other brands make great yo-yos with some vibe, but that may not fly with a brand you expect to be perfectly smooth.

3 Likes

Yeah, I can only speak to the expectation I’ve experienced from my customers.

8 Likes

Thank goodness for that.

2 Likes

Aha, isn’t this why many plastic yo-yos use brass for the bearing posts and bearing area as well?

3 Likes

Exactly. There’s room for both preferences, and both expectations.

1 Like